Sonic 1
Sonic 2
Sonic 3
Cheats
Games

Which one is the best?

November 16, 2020

  
  

Sonic 1 vs. Sonic 2

1- What are the advantages of each game?
2- What do you like most about each of them?
3- In your opinion which is the best, and why?

143 comments :

  1. 1-the advantages of each one is that they are easier unlike their original versions, that the physics are more worked in the remakes than in the originals, also having the super characters, and hyper sonic and hyper tails in the case of sonic 2 SMS Remake, and that both include new characters and new bosses.

    2-What I like the most about sonic 1 SMS Remake are all the zones with a new color palette, which feels like the zone is alive, and about sonic 2 SMS Remake I like one zone, Time Hill, really, I really enjoy that area, and putting the music that was the inspiration to make my favorite sonic cd Japanese version song, it's great.

    3-The best in my opinion is Sonic 2 SMS Remake, since it has more areas, more game modes and super and hyper transformations, make Sonic 2 SMS Remake an excellent game, and only one word defines this game, perfection!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sonic 1 for having four new zones directly taken from genesis.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 1.- Sonic 1 as it has its Sega Genesis areas but the third act of Star Light saddens me but it is good and Sonic 2 for the teams
    2. -Sonic 1 for its music and color palette and Sonic 2 for the extra areas and Super Sonic's boss
    3.- I think the Sonic 1 is better for the Sega Genesis areas, something that the Sonic 2 does not have
    PS: this is an extra but please Araya put a third starlight act as it would be great as act 1 of the oil ocean with Alex Kidd's motorcycle act 2 on foot enjoying the speed roads and platform and act 3 of the boss. I know this does not come to the topic but it would make me happy I like this area so I would like to know your answer thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I LIKE YOUR IDEA OF EXPANDING THE ZONE OF STAR LIGHT FROM TWO ACTS TO THREE CHOCHIN

      Delete
  6. SONIC 1 - IMPROVED GRAPHICS, SIMPLIFIED LEVELS, SUPER SONIC, FIVE PLAYABLE CHARACTERS, MEMORY CARDS, INVERTED SPECIAL STAGES.
    I LIKED SONIC 1: THE ABILITY TO GET EMERALDS ON SPECIAL STAGES, SUPER SONIC, EXCELLENT LEVELS. DIDN'T LIKE: SELECTION OF CHARACTER.
    SONIC 2-TEAMS, NEW LEVELS-OIL OCEAN AND TIME HILL, HYPER FORMS, SWITCHING BETWEEN CHARACTERS.
    I LIKED SONIC 2: TEAMS, SWITCHING BETWEEN CHARACTERS, SPECIAL STAGES, HYPER FORMS, FINAL BOSSES, NEW SCRAMBLED EGG LEVEL DESIGN.
    I LIKED SONIC 2: TEAMS, SWITCHING BETWEEN CHARACTERS, SPECIAL STAGES, HYPER FORMS, FINAL BOSSES, NEW DESIGN OF THE SCRAMBLED EGGS LEVEL.
    I LIKED SONIC 2: TEAMS, SWITCHING BETWEEN CHARACTERS, SPECIAL STAGES, HYPER FORMS, FINAL BOSSES, NEW DESIGN OF THE SCRAMBLED EGGS LEVEL.
    I LIKED SONIC 2: TEAMS, SWITCHING BETWEEN CHARACTERS, SPECIAL STAGES, HYPER FORMS, FINAL BOSSES, NEW DESIGN OF THE SCRAMBLED EGGS LEVEL.
    I THINK WHAT SONIC 2 IS BETTER, BECAUSE HERE IS ALL PERFECT!!! BUT THIS IS A MY OPINION!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sorry dude!!! i just like write big letters!!!

      Delete
  7. Prefiro o sonic 1 o sonic 2 é curto pra mim e muito fácil de conseguir vidas

    ReplyDelete
  8. i prefer both because there is minghy and ray i played them sice i was playing sonic manaia
    bwcause i more prefer sonic 1 sms remake

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1- novas esperiencias e personagens e supers
    2- as fases e musicas e o modo de salvar
    3- gostei de todos mas pra mim vale o sonic 2 enquanto o sonic 3 não chega
    Kkkkk

    ReplyDelete
  10. Ps: o ultra sonic poderia ter mais 3 poderes (polar solar e eco) poderia ser como esferavque contem esse poder como os anei e estrelas na forma ultra amarelos polar azul solar vermelho e eco verde que tal hein?

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1-Esmeraldas fáceis de adquirir
    2-Transformações e fases bonitas
    3-Sonic 1,por causa da nostalgia e ser o primeiro jogo que eu joguei na minha vida

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Concordo eu fui o último a mandar

      Delete
    2. Eu concordo pq eu jogo sonic 1 de master system e adorei esse jogo porque o jogo é a origem de alguns personagens da franquia sonic

      Delete
    3. eu tbm gosto de sonic 2 mas prefiro o sonic 1 e sonic 2

      Delete
  12. 1- What are the advantages of each game?
    1-adding new characters, new zones, the super and hyper transformations and better physics
    2- What do you like most about each of them?
    2-the variety of characters, especially in Sonic 2 SMS Remake with the mechanics of changing characters at specific times
    3- In your opinion which is the best, and why?
    3-this decision is very difficult, but in my opinion Sonic 2 SMS is better, both because it has new zones, a Hyper transformation and what I liked most was the addition of teams and new characters

    ReplyDelete
  13. os dois são bons só que o Sonic 2 e muito curto mais os dois são bons

    ReplyDelete
  14. 1 esmeraldas e super esmeraldas pois pra mim aquilo no sonic 2 são super esmeraldas
    2 fases novas criativas
    3 empatados

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think that Sonic 2 is better, since I like the zones, music and character selection more. Although i feel that the exclusion of green hills brings it down a bit. It also has a multiplayer mode coming, so thats an upside. Although i feel Sonic 2 is better, the extra zones in Sonic 1, might make it better than Sonic 2. Hopefully Green Hills (Maybe renamed to Emerald Hill) could be in a new update, since the addition of loops in starlight zone prove that Green Hills is possible. Maybe you could use the original music for it, and new music could be made for time hill. Or time hill could keep the music it has now, and an 8 bit remix of emerald hill 16-bit could be used. Maybe one day.

    ReplyDelete
  16. 1-de jogar com vários personagens da franquia
    2-as transformações já q nós jogos originais n tem super ou hyper
    3-Sonic 2 Porque só o fato de poder jogar com dois personagens em dupla já uma novidades e tbm cada personagens tem suas habilidades únicas

    ReplyDelete
  17. eu prefiro o sonic 2 e o 3 que vai lançar e o sonic 1 sonic 2 pq tem o hyper sonic sonic 1 pq vai ter o ultra sonic e sonic 3 pq parece ser legal quanto lançar

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. deixe o sonic do filme jogaveu e o tails do filme tambem

      Delete
  18. ok deixe o sonic do filme e tails do filme em dupla para jogar

    ReplyDelete
  19. I like both Sonic 1 And Sonic 2, they're both awesome fan games.
    From: SonicSmith9106

    ReplyDelete
  20. 1-as vantagens são que, diferente das versões de mega drive,as fases e habilidades do Sonic são diferentes, inclusive no Sonic 2,a história e fases são totalmente diferentes
    2--oq eu mais gosto no Sonic 1 é a simplicidade e os gráficos e trilha sonora,no Sonic 2 tbm são gráficos e trilha sonora,mas principalmente na história dele!
    3-prefiro o Sonic 2, pois ele tem uma história e fases totalmente diferentes em questão a sua versão 16 bit,e por ser um jogo muito legal e até mesmo desafiador!!!

    ReplyDelete
  21. https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/766873389687504896/778288185331286016/desconhecido.gif

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wcusa non vorrei farti arabbiare ma...sai che quello è il sonic 2 di sega genesis (Mega Drive) e non è di Sega Master System (Game Gear) ti chiedo scusa se ti arrabbierai

      Delete
  22. 1.every Sonic 1 has a new colour pallette and the story of Sonic 2 is revamped.
    2.Super and hyper transformations and new zones
    3.I love it both

    ReplyDelete
  23. I think hyper sonic should have the double jump and hyper tails should look like the super form but with flickies the super forms are already good they don't need change

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quintiliano : para de reclamar o araya fez o q a sega nunca fez

      Delete
    2. Quintiliano : e outra se o hyper tails fosse assim como vc quer seria sem graça

      Delete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. 1.no sonic 1 sms remake ordens da fases: green hill, marble, bridge, jungle, spring yard, labyrinth, star light, scrap brain,labyrinth 4 e sky base
    2.no sonic 2 sms remake efeitos sonoros do sonic 2 sms original e visualização da vida que e x3
    3.no sonic 3 triple chaos sms remake efeitos sonoros do sonic chaos ou triple trouble

    e essa é a minha ideia.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  26. Sonic 2 perché... Ci sono cose aggiuntive e in'oltre è il primo gioco che ho giocato di sonic dove posso prendere il master emerald

    ReplyDelete
  27. Penso che sia migliore sonic 2 sms remake sono che non devi fare così tante cose per sbloccare i personaggi e...Mighty e Ray sono i miei preferiti. Peró mi piace anche sonic 1 sms remake perché c'è per esempio la music fm che mi piace tantissimo che invece in sonic 2 non c'è e poi con la music FM cambia la musica di tutte le zone ristrutturandola un po' meglio quindi non saprei...comunque per me è in vantaggio sonic 2 anche per le mosse perché stando fermi si può notare che ci sono mosse di sonic che fa ma...in sonic 2 ce ne sono tante in sonic 1 ce ne solo una quindi quella sarà una cosa che aumentera la mia voglia di votare sonic 2 perciò o migliorano sonic 1 oppure credo proprio che voterò sonic 2

    ReplyDelete
  28. Sonic 2 sms remake,pois tem mais personagens,hyper sonic e hyper tails,mais fases,mecânicas inovadoras.

    ReplyDelete
  29. E inoltre in sonic 2 sms remake ci sono hyper sonic e hyper tails il mio primo gioco dove potevo provare le hyper forms

    ReplyDelete
  30. Sonic 1 because it has more content

    ReplyDelete
  31. If I had to say sonic 1 sms is the best

    ReplyDelete
  32. Sonic 2 pq tem o hyper s. e t.

    ReplyDelete
  33. no sonic 2 podia colocar um novo ícone do tails

    ReplyDelete
  34. Tem q ter hyper knuckles roxo claro

    ReplyDelete
  35. Sonic 2 Is The Best Because Is Already Have All Teams So Sonic 2 Is The Best

    ReplyDelete
  36. Sonic 2 reason more zones hipry sonic and tails new characters and comstome zones.

    ReplyDelete
  37. 1- What are the advantages of each game?
    1-Including characters from later games like cd and mania,New zones,The addition of super and hyper forms,New abilties,Better physics,Other cool stuff.
    2- What do you like most about each of them?
    2-The good choices of characters,The addition of extras like..Super forms,Collectible emeralds in special stages instead of being like a emerald hunt stage in each zone,New abilities,Options like new music,No super music,Boss health bar,Other things.
    3- In your opinion which is the best, and why?
    3-In my opinion,Sonic 2 Sms Remake is the best because it has new gymics,character switching,the addition of hyper and super forms.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Here's something regarding these questions, Creative Araya, Did you fix the glitch from https://youtu.be/idcPScFkPdg ?

    ReplyDelete
  39. will i think sonic sms 1 is better because it shows the power of that sonic sms 2 di not have

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hmmm acho que as opiniões vão depender se prefere o jogo original ou se está aberto a novas experiências.

    1- No Sonic 1 SMS temos um quase verdadeiro Remaster, com todas as zonas presentes em seus locais habituais, além de que traz de volta a Marble Zone e mais uma fases em breve. Temos assim um Sonic 1 SMS fiel ao original e com extras adicionados
    Sonic 2 SMS temos 2 personagens jogáveis em simultâneo com uma história adaptada e jogabilidade melhorada, além de ter também novas fases, special stages e novos bosses.

    2- No Sonic 1 SMS Remake eu adoro o facto de se manter fiel ao original e de adicionar fases do Mega Drive, fazendo a versão completa a mistura perfeita!
    No Sonic 2 SMS Remake adoro o sistema de equipas e o facto de fazer de um jogo que originalmente não gostava muito (o Sonic 2 SMS Original) um jogo clássico e divertido de se jogar sozinho ou com a família, sendo uma reimaginação melhorada!

    3- Eu quero deixar bem claro que eu amo tanto o Sonic 1 como o Sonic 2 SMS Remake mas para mim a vitória vai para o Sonic 2 SMS Remake pelo simples facto de que conseguiu tornar o Sonic 2 SMS (um jogo chato para mim) num jogo muito divertido e apelativo! Além disso o sistema de equipes tornou o jogo mais interessante!

    ReplyDelete
  41. Sonic 1 is for me the level design I like better, it is more replayable, it was the first one I played, when I played Sonic 2 I liked the mechanics of 2 characters but the level design I did not like at all anyway: Sonic 1 sms seems better to me (well until the release of sonic 3 sms so I tested I think it will beat both) but until it comes out I prefer sonic 1

    PS: will the new versions of these 2 games be released?
    I speak Spanish and I had to write this in the google translator
    Thanks for getting here I wish you a nice day

    ReplyDelete
  42. eu prefiro o sonic 2
    eu achei bem daora,mas seria legal tbm se tivesse opção de escolher quais sfx seriam
    tipo eu gosto muito das sound efects de sonic 2 do master,destruindo badnicks e atingindo chefes,o sfx dele caindo,o sfx de ganhando vida,o sfx de ganhando rings,o spin movement.
    mas eu achei muito legal o remake

    ReplyDelete
  43. sonic 1 a love marble zone

    ReplyDelete
  44. Sonic 1,sonic 2 and sonic chatos

    ReplyDelete
  45. sonic 2 na minha opinião

    ReplyDelete
  46. Replies
    1. a última versão do Sonic 1 e a versão 1.0.f!

      Delete
    2. Cara o João araya falou que a versão 1.0.F P2 vai ser conhecida como 1.0G

      Delete
    3. o que munda na versão 1.0.g? eu quero saber

      Delete
    4. Vai pra baixo e tem uma parte em que o João explicou em 1 post

      Delete
  47. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Will sonic 2 sms get the sonic mania partner system were the second character still follows but can swap between the 2.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Sonic 1 é meh o 2 é uma delisia cara

    ReplyDelete
  50. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Sonic 2 ha più potenziale perché Mighty e Ray si sbloccano gratis e Mighty e Ray sono i miei preferiti della serie e inoltre in sonic 2 c'è Hyper Sonic mentre in sonic 1 c'è solo super sonic l'unico vantaggio che potrebbe avere Sonic 1 è quello del music FM perché come ho detto ristruttura la musica di tutte le zone ed è gratis! Quindi non c'è competizione sonic 2 è meglio anche perché in sonic 2 hanno aggiunto dei nuovi personaggi:Shadow, Metal Sonic e Amy. Un altro vantaggio che potrebbe avere sonic 1 è quello che si può fare lo spindash con tutti i personaggi invece in sonic 2 puoi fare lo spindash solo con il capo della coppia che selezioni...ma comunque si vede la differenza sonic 2 ha più vantaggi sonic 1 ha solo 2 vantaggi rispetto a sonic 2 che ne ha molti. Secondo me era meglio dire che ognuno ha i suoi gusti ma se devo scegliere per forza scelgo sonic 2 ma...non è ancora ufficiale

    ReplyDelete
  52. Sonic 2 è meglio anche perché in sonic 2 puoi sbloccare Mighty e Ray gratis e poi sonic 2 ha Hyper Sonic mentre sonic 1 ha solo super sonic e poi in sonic 2 ci sono nuovi personaggi:Shadow,Metal Sonic e Amy. Un vantaggio che può avere sonic 1 è la Music FM perché come ho detto ristruttura la musica di tutte le zone ed è gratis! Inoltre sonic 2 ha un boss finale è molto bello perché il vero boss finale fa riferimento a sonic 3 genesis (Mega Drive) perché sei nello spazio e combatti con super sonic! E inoltre in sonic 2 c'è l'aggiunta del master emerald e inoltre special stage molto più facili. Un altro piccolissimo vantaggio che ha sonic 1 è quello che puoi fare lo spindash con tutti i personaggi mentre in sonic 2 puoi fare lo spindash solo con il capo della coppia...comunque anche se penso che sarebbe meglio dire che ognuno hai suoi gusti ma se devo scegliere per forza scelgo sonic 2...ma non è ancora ufficiale la mia scelta devo cercare ancora dei vantaggi che magari non ho osservato di entrambi i giochi.

    ReplyDelete
  53. no sonic 1,2 e 3 triple chaos todos detalhes podia ser do jogo original do jeito que eu gosto.

    ReplyDelete
  54. principalmente os physics pra ficar melhor.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Sonic 2 is best. Sonic 2 has more levels and extras than Sonic 1

    ReplyDelete
  56. Sonic 2 has more levels than Sonic 1
    Sonic 2 has more extras than Sonic 1
    All the characters are free in Sonic 2

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sonic 2 has hypersonic and that's good Sonic 1 don't have hypersonic and you got to collect the characters in Sonic 1

      Delete
  57. 1. Sonic 1 has the additional genesis zones. Sonic 2 has better music, zones and characters.
    2. I like that there are many extra genesis zones in Sonic 1. I like Sonic 2s Title screen menu, music, characters, levels and mechanics more.
    3. Overall, I prefer sonic 2, but both are excellent. I might change my mind when the new genesis zones release though.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Sonic 1 SMS remake cause it's a remake, not a completely different game, with new layouts, that don't even fit for Ray's ability [i am looking at Gimmick Mt.]

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like more Sonic 2 SMS , but you have a good and clear opinion.

      Delete
  59. I would think they're both fun in their own right. Although the hyper forms introduced in sonic 2 makes completing the game more rewarding. The thing is, it seems sonic is the only one who loses his unique ability when tranformed, his peelout. When sonic is super or hyper, the peelout is disabled, for some reason, makimg him almost a generic character with no special ability in comparison to the other characters, who retain their abilities when transformed. That takes a bit away from both of the games, to me. Just an idea, in sonic 3 heroes, if you draw from the archie sonic comics for inspiration, the sonic 3 version of super tails, with the flickies was adapted to be tails' ultra form in the comics, so that could possibly be used, if when sonic goes ultra, you would add forms to the other characters to the team. Since knuckles in the comics never seems to have an ultra form, I would think the closest approximation would be "chaos knuckles". Of course, this was only an idea if you were to add ultra forma to tails and knuckles, but if you don't, you can ignore this part of my post.

    ReplyDelete
  60. 1.) Sonic 1 SMS is more faithful to both Sonic 1 Genesis and Sonic 1 Master System. I like this because it means I'm getting the same game, just better. Sonic 2 SMS feels like a new game disguised as a remake, with totally new mechanics and way less frustration. This makes the game feel more unique compared to Sonic 1 SMS.
    2.) I like how simple Sonic 1 SMS is, but I also like how different and complex Sonic 2 SMS is in comparison.
    3.) I prefer Sonic 2 SMS because of how unique it is. Sonic 1 SMS just feels like a remake with a good chunk of additional content, which is still good, but Sonic 2 SMS takes it a step further.

    ReplyDelete
  61. I like sonic 1 because everyone can spindash and it is just miles better

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. oh and if you want to know, i unlocked all the characters in one run in time attack after i had gotten all the emeralds in normal play, my reccord was 11:45

      Delete
    2. and i played the latest version so i could go on by as tails

      Delete
  62. Sonic 2 por que tem muito mais conteúdo que o um e por que o jogo original foi até antes de lançar um dos melhores se não o melhor jogo do Sonic que tem o mesmo titulo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Não tem como descorda de vc sonic 2 e melhor por ter mais conteudo

      Delete
  63. Just a question, what happened to marble zone in the sonic 1 game?

    ReplyDelete
  64. Os dois são bons ,mas eu gostei mais do sonic 2

    ReplyDelete
  65. Eu gostei da música do hiper Sonic gosto do Sonic 2

    ReplyDelete
  66. Sonic 2 e melhor por ter mais conteudo

    ReplyDelete
  67. Hello João!

    I am going to list some of the things a think could really help making Sonic 1 better, so let's go!

    So the first three suggestions are URGENT. I think they really need to change, and by doing so, it would help to make the game waaay better

    1st - Sonic could be placed in the middle of the screen, in the center, offering more vision to the player, that will be able to see whats coming in his/her way

    2nd - The camera really need some improvement! The way it is now, it follows sonic whenever he jumps, and doesnt allow the player to see whats bellow. My suggestion is that you make like it is in the genesis, where the camera only tilts up with sonic after he reaches some height.

    3rd - Special Stage IV emerald placement just sucks. Im sorry. It could be more centralized

    I would also suggest some more smooth animations, with two or three more in-between frames for the characters, and the enemies too, but a know these are just aesthetic changes.

    The game is great, though. Improving the camera would make it really perfect.

    Best Wishes!

    ReplyDelete
  68. How do you play soinc 1 8 bit I tryed for a hour and I still do not know how to do it can anyone help me please

    ReplyDelete
  69. Por favor faz um Sonic Chaos

    ReplyDelete
  70. I like sonic 1 SMS more too, For the same reason but also the fact that I just like being solo (Yeah, I know that you can just not swap....but still.)

    ReplyDelete
  71. I like BOTH games, altough I find them to be too much on the easy side. Anyway, I'm loving your work, do no stop for anything in this world!

    ReplyDelete
  72. I think sonic 1 is better for multiple reasons like it has more extra's and also sonic 2 hasn't really had a lot of development since the last update and yet sonic 1 is having a lots of updates also i think for the new level you should mix star light and stardust speedway to see what it might look like and with a background that shows the sky and tip of the mountains of spring yard zone and bits of labyrinth tiles would be in the one.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Sonic 2 Is My Favourite because i like the time hill zone,and has debug mode and changed zones (nice)

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.